India Smoking bans hit hard
India has banned smoking in public places, including all offices and restaurants, citing economic costs and the need to stem the loss of human lives. Smokers caught in violation of the ban face a fine of Rs200 (US$4).
While the ban continues to rankle India's tobacco industry, which claims the ban infringes on individual rights, observers point out that actually enforcing it is likely to be problematic. This has certainly been the case with past efforts to eradicate public spitting and urination.
Nonetheless, ITC, India's largest cigarette manufacturer, has mounted a legal challenge against the ban. The case came before the Supreme Court last November 18.
In a related move, the health ministry is urging a complete ban on foreign direct investment (FDI) in the domestic tobacco industry and is seeking to impose greater taxes on tobacco products.
"The health ministry is totally opposed to fresh overseas funds infusion in spite there being 100% FDI in the tobacco sector," Said health secretary Naresh Dayal. "We have also asked the finance ministry to impose more taxes on cigarettes and other tobacco products such as gutkha and pan masala."
The proposed ban on FDI is apparently not supported by the department of industrial policy & promotion (Dipp), government department tasked with approving foreign investment.
"When 100% FDI in the tobacco sector is allowed, banning it would be considered an investor-unfriendly policy and send negative signals to the investor world," according to an unnamed Dipp source.